The Debate | Oil-Based Vs. Water-Based Hair Products
- Posted on 21 August, 2016
- Hair Care
- By Anonymous
There's long been a debate about what's better - oil-based or water-based hair products?
In this video, I'll compare both talking about the difference between oil-based and water-based; identifying the product; styling; the finish; re-styling; washing the products out; your skin; and what's best for you.
______________________
I'M WEARING:
Denim jacket - http://rstyle.me/n/buf6cab6ah7
Prescription glasses - Ray-Ban (RB 7097 5633)from David Clulow - http://robin.yt/2bEjMMI)
______________________
IN THE BACKGROUND:
Bomber jacket - http://rstyle.me/n/buf6fmb6ah7
_______________________
MY HAIRCUT:
- My hair was cut 1 week before this video was filmed. It was a 0 clipper back and sides.
- The top comes down to the bottom of my nose.
- It's longer in the front than the back.
I'VE STYLED IT WITH:
- Aveda Thickening Tonic - http://rstyle.me/~8EvEo
- Fudge Elevate Styling Powder - http://rstyle.me/n/buqwjvb6ah7
- Kevin Murphy Free Hold - http://amzn.to/2bVjHsw
_______________________
FOLLOW ME!
Come and follow me on...
Facebook: /ManForHimself
Twitter: @ManForHimself
Instagram: @ManForHimself
Snapchat: @ManForHimself
Check out my blog too: http://www.ManForHimself.com
________________________
SUBSCRIBE
My YouTube channel is a destination for men's style, lifestyle and grooming.
I make videos showing how to achieve different hairstyles and haircuts; exploring grooming products; and showcasing men's seasonal and trend led style and fashion.
________________________
MUSIC:
Beyond - Lakey Inspired - https://soundcloud.com/lakeyinspired/b...
________________________
This video is not sponsored.
Hi guys, how are you I'm Robin welcome back to my channel now? One of the questions that you guys asked the most is the difference between products, especially when it comes to water-based products versus oil-based products. Also, I find out first hand that there's quite a debate around this online, so I thought I'd go through the difference between these products really sort of weigh them up together and help you guys decide what's really best for you. We all know that hair products are so subjective and all depends on your hair type, a hair, so you want and also the lifestyle you lead, I'm going to be talking a bit about the debate, the difference between them identifying what that hair product is styling. The finish restyling washing out a bit about your skin and also guys what best for you in case you guys didn't know, there's actually quite a debate over there with loads of guys being involved in different Facebook groups, all about traditional techniques, pomades and sort of traditional Products and I've seen my videos shared on there before, which is great reviews. Thank you for sharing, but guys I have kind of been ripped to shreds in terms of my techniques and what I do, and you know, people really berating. The fact that I use a hairdryer and a hair spray - that's great, that's totally cool, but actually my channels not about that. It'S about sort of getting scripts of yourself and really trying out different products that suit you and your lifestyle. So really guys, I would say, as my retort to them, welcome to 2016 the year of choice, who, quite simply, the main difference between oil based and water based products are that oil based products are hydrophobic, meaning that they're repelled water and they won't dissolve in water. Whereas water-based products will dissolve in water and that's really as simple as it gets guys, you do get more modern, hybrid products which kind of confused the whole thing up and they don't sit in either camp and they might have sort of always properties, but they will Wash out with water, identifying of a hair products, water-based or a base is actually pretty easy. Now there are some products that give always straight away, they might say something like water-based or water soluble or washes I easily. That, generally will mean it is water-based, but you still want to check the ingredients now, just like food and drink the stuff, that's at the top of that list for the ingredient is has, most of so, if it says aqua or water, it means it's water-based and Generally, you'll have formal chemicals in that in terms of formulation of the product. Now guys oil-based will generally say that it's got something like beeswax or petroleum, or soft paraffin at the very top, and they will generally have less things in the formulation. Now, when it comes to styling, this is where it is so up to the individual now watch bridge products tend to be a lot lighter, so you can get throughout your hair evenly a lot easier, whereas all based products tend to be a lot thick and consistency And really require to warm that product up before putting it through the hair and you can get little lumps and bumps, so you really do want to warm it up now. If you want to go for something like a traditional palm or a real greaser, then guys without a doubt, I would say: go for the oil-based product, especially if that's a style. You do absolutely. Every day now, water-based products will dry harden your hair, meaning that they'll give a good hold guys, but really they will lose their shine throughout the day, also, if you're using a slightly cheaper product and they might call flake in your hair, which is never good. Now all these products won't dry hard and they'll keep being malleable, so you can sort of really work fast out throughout the day and they'll also retain their shine. This is where it really comes down to lifestyle, and when I talk about restyling I mean you know how easy is it to change that style with the same product or kind of just add a little bit more volume, obviously, with the oil based product, as I've Said they don't dry hard, so you can wake up the next day or just late in the evening before going out, grab a comb work. That'S pumped back in get a little bit more volume and kind of put that power back in if it's been messed up, whereas with a Water Bridge product because it dries hard, you're, not gon na, be able to restyle that again it's going to set where it Is you can add a little bit of water to kind of reactivate that, but I think it's just going to mess up, so I would never really recommend that makes a wash out and start again watching your hair is generally another lifestyle choice. I would say: if you're going for that sort of pomp Luke, can you always use an oil-based product, then generally you're not going to be changing the product and you're just kind of neaten up that style everyday, but guys if you're, someone like me, a guy who Changes hairstyles so often, and you like to change up your products. Then an oil-based product is not going to be great for you, because every time you want to remove that you're gon na have to use a really good cleansing, shampoo and actually, in my experience of using all these products, I find that I've had to shampoo my Hair two, maybe even three times to get all that build-up, oh, but guys are using a water-based product. You can generally just hop in the shower, not use a whoo and Renzo all of that product. With these now, I just kind of wanted to touch on this point, and this is not a Tommy scaremongering. We'Re saying that all base products are bad for you, but in my experience when I have used oil based products and I've slept with them in my hair, I've woken up see into a few days and I've had a breakout in my forehead and I've had a Little sports and that's really just because I've slept with it across my skin. It was absolute, my own fault and I've got quite oily skin anyway, so having that oil against it will tend to block the pores and cause spot, but guys if you can keep her off your forehead, you can keep it off your skin. Then you should be absolutely fine, also talking about sleeping with it in your hair. If you sleep with it against a white pillows or black clothes, even you can see that oily sort of secretion on your pillows and oil generally doesn't wash out of things that easily. So keep that in mind if you are sleeping where you're so best linen so finally, the right product for you is up to you again, it's totally up to you and I'm keep on saying this to keep on banging on, but it's lifestyle choices. It'S about what suits you, the Styles, you do and the sort of lifestyle you lead and guys for the people that been ripping my video to I was going to say, but let's go to shreds a very sad now and keep going. That'S absolutely fine! You give me a few views which is good. Let'S keep everything in perspective. I'M happy, I'm healthy. That'S all that matters. If you're happy you're healthy, then you pick whatever hair product you want. You know we're not changing the world. With this. I know I've got a few YouTube channel dedicated to style, excellent grooming, but I'm about giving people options to make the most of you. I think that's what Matt is and but thank you so much for watching guys what we've enjoyed this one. If you did and you've not yet press subscribed, then press subscribe, it's there or it's down there. It is free, and it just means you're, going to see all my new videos as soon as they called life, but guys also, if you're mobile, hit that little Bell button on my channel, I'm just going to get a notification as soon as it goes up. I'M going to see you in my next new one you're gon na get a notification on Thursday, bye, bye,
Comments
xHibachi24x: "Welcome to 2016, the year of choice." I absolutely love this stance Robin. Instead of getting defensive and feeding into the haters/trolls, you're just spreading good vibes and information. Keep it up brother. I'm sure it's already obvious, but the fans you have far outnumber the haters who try to bring ya down. Keep it up brother! Hope to see more awesome videos like this. P.S. I really enjoy you giving us the preview of what you'll be talking about in the beginning. It really helps bring the video together instead of other videos where there's no sense of direction.
Dhruv Mehta: Absolutely love your attention to detail; From the information in the video, to your description in the description box. Thoroughly love it ! Keep it up
Jonny Lister: Keep up the great videos robin! You give us top advice and then I guess we can decide what to do with it and/or take tips and apply to our own styles
theldtiii: I found this review 2 years late, but it was super helpful and informative none the less. Thank you.
Max Button: I've got to say this channel has come such a long way ever since you have launched the Man for Himself brand. Its a much more slick and put together channel. Its one of my favourites on YouTube.
Nicholas McKee: Hey Robin. I guess I'm on the side of water-based, simply because of the ease-of-use. I was wondering, do you have an opinion on the AXE/Lynx hair products? They have just updated their line. I might give them a try because they're only $6 (€5.30). Btw those glasses look great on you (not trying to kiss your ass).
W.S.R.- The Wet Shaver Review: Robin, I tend to use the product that most fits the styles needs. As you said a traditional Pomp or greaseback is a hand down oil based hair day. The FaceBook groups tend to be purists and are rough on those that don't follow the mold they set. I prefer water based products as they wash out every night without shampoo; what's better than that ? I love American Crew products as well Schwartzkoff which btw certain water based Pomades are restylable and have a flex hold. Last thing is a trick for oil based users, if you use the traditional "Groom & Clean" hair product (just a dime size) and work it into your build up or, daily style; it will rinse out just like a water base. Keep looking sharp gents !
Francisco Orozco: I love all your videos Robin, dunno' why I feel that I can Identify myself w/ the way you use and appreciate hair products
Juan Andrade: Honestly waiting for this topic thanks so much Robin !
Charles Kaplan: Very informative videos. Can anything can be done with wearing a wool cap or hood attachment for the winter months. When I go indoors my hair is out of control -- brushing or combing doesn't seem to help. I do use a clay, but if there is a product that will keep the hair in place after removing the cap or hood, please let me know.
Robin James: I’ve wanted to film this one for a while. I find the whole debate pretty interesting! It’s all about personal choice, IMHO.
Mean Gene: I have hybrid pomade, advertise as water base pomade organic, .. But the effect doesn't feel like water base, it feels like 50% waterbase 50% oil base... I like to use moose everyday, i really love my hybrid water base pomade, it was made by the barbers specification for the pompadour hair style..
Erin Kaye Ozga: Great information Robin! Always learning from you
Julian X: Thank you a lot for the info Robin! I'm getting an oil based pomade. Thanks!
Albi Snow: The thing is, I've never had a big problem with washing out oil based products. I have used Lockharts heavy and heavies are supposed to be very difficult to be washed out. It would just take one shampoo and conditioning to get it out, maybe two if I use a lot so I don't really care if it's water or oil based.
multimanfail: I used to use gatsby's wax and i need to wash my hair about 2 to 3 times to get it out. Ive decided to increase my budget and get higher end products like HDF or by vilain. It costs me about 3 times more than usual but at least i have fun styling my hair now
Austin Meehan: Great video (again) and thanks for clearing up some question marks
Heir: Thanks for the info, ive been wanting to know about this for a while!
Siberius Wolf: What clay products are there that are water based first in the ingredients, meaning they wash out easily.. only 2 that you have reviewed fit the bill, it would be cool to see more of those.
David Harkess: Thanx for this vid Robin. great info again. I swear Hanz De Fuko Clamation is the best product to date for my hair, I use it on damp hair and I can re-style it throughout the day. keep up the great work that you do.
speakthetruth: I have really thick hair and shampooing dries my hair out so I only do that once a week, but I am using v05 reWork putty daily is using water okay or should I really be making sure I get it out in the shower? Love your videos :) Thank you and have a lovely day.
Casper White: Any recommendations for water based products for curly hair ?
Shamana Rofaeel: really liking the higher quality videos!
Kraig Highnam: You're awesome, Robin. Always enjoy your videos.
Matt Pritchard: I find on days when I don't wash my hair that I can get oil based products out by just clawing at my hair in the shower and I've got really thick hair so it's odd that I find them easy to get out
Infinity: I want a product that’ll make my hair look wet and like where my hair kind of moves around as I move Any suggestions?
Emmanuel Benítez: Hi! I have a very big question. Using oil pomade can lead to hair fall? I've heard that the oil can clog the pores, and i don't know if i should shower in the morning and at night (you know, because i'm not sure if i should sleep with it) i would appretiate a reply. Thank you very much!
FURY GAMING: Great video, great debate! i use water based products because i shampoo my hair only once or twice a week.
Ishmam A.: and robin! your videos get better and better. plus those frames fit you quite well ☺
Luxury Vienna: For anybody trying to wash out an oil based pomade: take a conditioner, same amount as pomade, massage it in your hair and wait for 10-15 minutes. Then get in the shower and wash your hair just one time with shampoo. Your hair will be completely pomade free after that. Great video by the way!
NelsonGamezYT: Robin it tears my heart to hear that people are hating on your videos. They are probably jealous of you/hair/your products. I love you Robin. KEEP DONG WHAT YOU ARE DOING.
DienarNash: This cute girl I had a crush on says my hair looks to damn greasy. She was like "did you put cooking oil on your hair?" That was like... kinda make me... Sigh... Been using water based for lower shine ever since.
shahzad khan: HELPED ALOT! THANK YOU!
TheWoogie2: Nice video! Just out of curiosity, what kind of product did you have in your hair in this video?
Ligh†: Hey robin great vid! I was just wondering what shampoo and conditioner do you use?
Shubham Singh: Robin could you please give some suggestions about what products should a person with dry and slightly wavy hair use?
King Dragon: Hey Robin, have you ever tried any Lockhart's products? Like their matte clay or goon grease?
MBLUEWARRIOR 31: How should I grow my hair out to have a great pompadour? Should it be really short in the back or almost the same length as the front?
RA: i tried only one oil based pomade. never again. oil based is off for me. i go for water based because i hate to wash my hair with shampoo every day
Bai Jrav: Hey Robin would you reccomend Claymation, Baxters, or Star Wax Clay? I have fine hair, and lots of it if that helps?
Isaac Victor Blanco: You should have 1 million subs great content
LucaLifestyle: Obsessed !!! I loooove your Videos soooo much :O You are such an inspiration..wow !
huy ngo: Oil based is love Oil based is life
eli hauser: Love the glasses, I need a new pair but round glasses don't work with my face
MATTisdope: Bro your sooooo close to 100k u deserve every single one of your subs
Yellowstone: im Using beeswax clay and wax for my hair. Il wash it every second day and it Works ok
Rockken in TEXAS: What product keeps hair from drying out
Eamonn Shields: I'm a chef and you don't want to see my hair. unfortunately I would love to have the time to do a big pomp every day but unfortunately I don't have time to even get a routine every day. your videos are cool man.
El Ch3po: thanks bro Robbin i have not used shampoo for a week and my hair looks fresh
Hunter Plax: Can you please do an honest review on Mitch clean cut semi matte product???
Patrick Teoh: He deserves to have a million subscribers
Luke Hodson: so baically: if you want to do a slick style everyday 24/7 choose an Oil based. If not cop a water based
Ivan Samaniego: Do oil based products cause hair loss?
Conner Souza: Great work Robin I think you should do a video on glasses
Ruoson: Hey Robin, can you recommend me any good oil-based products?
Rebel cowboy Elvis: can you do a video on how to do an elephant's trunk with hair gel I would really appreciate it I've tried and cannot figure it out for the life of me thank you and as always Rebel cowboy Elvis out
Hrishi Phulsundar: Nice one robin, when i use oil based product and having sweat that oil comes on my forehead so I switched to water based products...
blastoise96: I really wish you could do my hair every single day
Brandon Rivera: " Welcome to 2016, the year of choice. " lol rekt
Mojo Risin’: Bravo Robin
Eagle black: this was very useful
Moamen Elsabea: If am using oil based pomade should i wash it every night or will be able to leave it in my hair till next day or gonna cause a dandruff, have no idea ...
aqil iman: hai robin,i love all your videos
HUNTISMONKEY: Thanks for using hairdryers even tho the haters come and attack u
saheeda navab: My hair got dry and rough after using hair products. Please tell me what i should do.
Tam Dao: im asain so what should i use since my hair sticks out and its strong
clif benit: hi what brand of water base product you use?
Adrian Martinez: you should a back to school essentials video
Corey Bycraft: Can you do a hair spray review
Jay Wicks: Top video Robin! Glasses
J_RF: Interesting to say the least
Tavito Silva: can you review daimon barber's clay pomade
Amandeep Johal: Robin what do you think of Muk products? A lot of the barbers/hairdressers I have used this line of products.
ink: Dear Robin, please post links to some Facebook groups.....
Hyperanium: which category does clay fall in?
Indra pepe: Great
Punishable Animations: HAHAHAHAHA, these glasses look so horrible, had a really good laugh, thank you! AHHAHA
J Kellan: If only there was a good water based wax.
Brady Jones: What are these forums he is referring to in the beginning?
Flovv: What is the best water based clay pomade for short hair something with a good hold for spiked up look
Grand Mapussydestoryer666: the only oil based pomade i know is murrays. can anyone tell me more about oil based pomade please? (:
Alpha's #1 fan: oil base is way better IMO also like that build up feel.
Abdul Rahman Mohamed: nice vid Robin
kijk kanaal: Robin do you Think reuzel (green) is a good oil based product
Eamonn Shields: Hey man I think I have the same hair texture as you
Kazuki Souji: you have a new subscriber
Pratik grg: What is hair wax based on
موسى العطواني:
Vintaage: Those glasses look amazing
Mike Zigi: So if someone is doing the same hairstyle everyday oil is better ?
Nicholas Lee: Do a Nathan Sykes hairstyle tutorial pls
shotbygem: robin I'm going to be completely honest. those glasses don't work for you. the hair is great. go back to the other frames
MyNameIsJufre: what is his hairstyle called?
papabless: La la, la laa, warm it up
Vipul Pawar: u tell them Robin
Squat every day: 1:25 get rekt
shahzad khan: FIRST!!
Oopsie Poopsie: Is he a gay?
Jonathan awx: THIRD BITCHES
Jeslin Jose: Third